Sermon by the Rev. Caela Simmons Wood
First Congregational UCC of Manhattan, KS
Matthew 28:16-20
September 20, 2026
“What are the consequences of thinking that your intelligence or personality is something you can develop, as opposed to something that is a fixed, deep-seated trait?” [1]
This is the question psychologist Carol Dweck has spent her life trying to answer. In doing so, she’s become one of those rare psychologists whose ideas and theories have so permeated the zeitgeist that you’ve been impacted by her work even if you’ve never heard her name.
Dweck is the person who came up with the concept of fixed and growth mindsets. When we believe our skills, talents, intelligence are innate - that we did well on a test because we’re smart or that we scored the winning goal because we’re naturally a good athlete - we’re seeing ourselves through a fixed mindset.
When we believe that our skills, talents, intelligence are malleable - that we can get a higher grade next time if we work hard or that we can make our sprint a little faster with the right effort - we’re operating with a growth mindset.
It turns out the internal monologue we have about our efforts, successes, and failures makes an enormous impact on our lives. When we lean into a fixed mindset, we often fail to apply ourselves. A low grade on a test can become a catastrophic incident because it not only means we did poorly on one test, it suddenly means we’re stupid and there’s no point in trying. And we’re less likely to try hard things because we’re so afraid of failure. Meaning, we don’t grow much because we’re not practicing like we could be.
Conversely, a growth mindset can help us stick with all kinds of challenging tasks. Messing up the presentation might be embarrassing, but it’s not a character judgment. And we have a lot to learn from our failures because there’s always room for growth.
While recently re-reading Dweck’s 2006 book, Mindset, I had one of those “mind blown” moments. She was writing about how much power we give to other people’s assessments of our skills and worth - and she looked at it through a gendered lens. Dweck writes that women often learn to put a high degree of trust in other people’s opinions of them. As girls, they may be praised often for being pleasing, kind, well-behaved, helpful. And so they feel good about themselves. Which is all well and good until they make a mistake. And someone calls them on it. And suddenly the whole world is disintegrating because “if someone else says it, it must be true.”
Boys, on the other hand, are criticized and scolded often. Dweck and her team found that in an elementary school classroom, boys received eight times the criticism the girls did for their behavior. And, she says, boys are also more likely to tease each other - calling each other names and openly criticising each other. From this, boys may learn not to put too much stock in what others think of them. They might learn to look to their own internal assessments as the authority instead.
MIND BLOWN.
I couldn’t help but think of Dweck this week when I read Jesus’s words in Matthew’s Gospel: “all authority on heaven and earth has been given to me.”
ALL AUTHORITY? On heaven AND earth? That’s a lot of authority! What does that even mean?
Dweck is talking about authority with her mindsets. Do we look to others to assess our worth? Or do we have an intrinsic sense of it ourselves? Do we allow a fixed or growth mindset to tell us what a high or low test grade means?
Jesus would say, “You’re overthinking all of this, folks. It’s easy. All authority on heaven and earth has been given to me.” Boom. That’s it.
Now authority is a word that chafes for many. Perhaps we don’t want to be told what to do. We’ve had bad experiences with giving too much authority away. We’ve been preyed upon by authorities who used their power-over in damaging ways.
Biblical scholar Osvaldo Vena says that in Matthew’s Gospel the word “authority” is “always used in connection with Jesus’s acts of healing and forgiveness.” He says Christ’s authority is “not an authority that demands people’s submission but rather an authority that empowers and liberates.” [2]
Authority, like power, is neutral. It becomes healing or harmful depending on who is exercising it and the way in which they do so.
And so, when Jesus, the one who came to us made in the image of God’s Love, the one who ate with sinners and questioned those in power, the one who healed and taught about love, the one who laid down his life in solidarity with the oppressed - when Jesus says he has all authority, it seems to me this authority is meant to free us, not hem us in.
Because to say that Jesus has all authority is ALSO to say that there are many other powers that do NOT have authority: the numbers in our bank account, our test scores, the aches and pains and limitations of our bodies. To say that Jesus has all authority is to say that unhealthy or abusive relationships, fear and anxiety, addictions and mental health struggles, these do not have ultimate authority. To say that Jesus has all authority is to claim that it’s actually not our algorithms and social media feeds, our boss, the mayor, the governor, the president that have authority over our lives.
Can I get an Amen?
At the end of the day, we all have something that is our ultimate authority. Named or not. Examined or not. We all have a God, even if we call it by another name. The question is not whether we have an ultimate authority in our lives: the question is, “what is it?”
Jesus says it’s Love. Everything else gets measured against this plumb line for Jesus: “Love God and love your neighbor and yourself.” His life, his ministry, his death, his resurrection - they all point towards this authority.
To say that Love has ultimate authority is not just a theological or philosophical claim. Because Love is an action word. Love comes with strings attached. In the profound and powerful words of bell hooks “Love is as love does. Love is an act of will - namely, both an intention and an action.” [3]
And so we should not be surprised that immediately after Jesus claims all authority on heaven and earth, he launches into concrete expectations for his followers, “Go and share the good news of God’s love with others. Baptize them and welcome them into the community. Teach them so they can keep learning alongside you. And always remember, you don’t go alone. I am with you. Always.”
If we are to go and do all the things Love asks us to do, we need to get serious about preparing for the journey. Because there are a lot of wannabe authorities that would love to sell us their version of reality instead. If we are to go and do all the things Love asks of us, we have to stop spending so much time doom scrolling and numbing and consuming the twenty-four hour news cycle that continually tells us we’re all about to die in the next decade.
And lest you think I’m picking on you, I’m preaching to myself here, too.
I usually do a pretty good job of telling those wannabe authorities to “shhhhh” and simmer down. But there are days when they seem so loud. Days when I want to curl up under a cozy blanket and hide from all the bad things in our world.
When I do that - when I retreat to the fortress of a dark blanket on my couch - I try to remember to carry Jesus’s words with me. Because his promise that all authority belongs to him is a balm for my weary soul.
If Jesus has all authority, it means that the relentless news cycle about AI is scary, but it’s not the ultimate authority in our lives.
If Jesus has all authority, it means that climate change is terrifying, but it’s not the end of the story.
If Jesus has all authority, it means elections will come and go. It means there is no politician or political party that has all the answers - though they sure would like you to think so.
If Jesus has all authority, it means that when the midterms are over, our work is the same. Keep showing up. Keep listening and learning. Keep speaking up on behalf of the least, the lost, and the last. Keep telling stories that bring healing and hope. Keep pointing to Love as the ultimate authority. Keep doing justice, loving mercy, walking humbly.
The work doesn’t change because the authority never changes.
It’s always Love.
In this world filled with wannabe authorities, where, in your life do you find space to commune with Love? It might be in daily prayer or time with the Bible. It might be through music or art. Or chopping vegetables or weeding your garden. Maybe you find Love when you’re volunteering or hugging a tree. If all authority belongs to Jesus then we are invited and compelled to nurture daily practices that help us tune out the wannabes and tune into the Christ Force that surrounds us.
Last Friday, on the 25th anniversary of September 11th, I found myself in a retreat center in rural Oklahoma, beginning the day with silent prayer. I was surprised to find that what I needed most in that time was to cry. I wept for all the horrific things that have come to pass in the last 25 years - September 11th, war after war, school shootings, the horrors of white supremacy, the rise of fascism, the pain of our planet, COVID….plus, of course, the all the difficulties unique to my own life.
And when I reached the end of my tears, I received a gift. It was quiet. I had to really focus to make out the words. But it sounded like this: “Lo, I am with you always, even to the end of the age.”
Always. Always. Always.
Thanks be to God.
NOTES:
[1] Carol Dweck. Mindset.
[3] bell hooks. All About Love.
.jpeg)