Genesis 18
Sermon by the Rev. Caela Simmons Wood
First Congregational UCC of Manhattan, KS
August 10, 2025
This morning’s topic is sin. Specifically the sin of Sodom. Which is, incidentally, probably not what you think it is. But we’ll get to that a little later.
First, though, I wanted to talk about sin in the United States of America.
Earlier this week, I sat around a table with other faith leaders here in Manhattan. Meeting the needs of our neighbors is always high on the list of agenda items, and the conversation turned to those in our community who don’t have safe and adequate shelter. As you might expect, folks who live and work in the downtown area have noticed those without homes more lately, probably because there are fewer options for safe shelter in the summer months.
In the winter, we have the Center of Hope, but homelessness doesn’t take a break when it gets warmer outside. And numbers have been creeping up at Common Table, too: 70-75 mightly dinner guests were the norm in July. Those who volunteer regularly at Common Table or Center of Hope or the Breadbasket any of the other social service agencies in town, know these neighbors by their names. We recognize them as beloved children of God - just like the rest of us. Full of beauty and complexity - full of good jokes and inappropriate ones, too - ready to open a door or share a smile - sometimes surly or angry, sometimes joyful or mischievous. Our neighbors are beings with hopes, dreams, fears, worries, desires, needs. Just like the rest of us.
I said I’m going to talk about sin. I’m getting there.
So, as we were discussing our neighbors at this ministerial meeting, someone mentioned that they had recently been in a meeting with some downtown business owners. And the same topic - our neighbors - came up. Only in THIS meeting, our neighbors were referred to as a “vagrancy problem.”
Now, I am not naive. I understand that groups of people - all kinds of people - are imperfect and can cause problems. But this language - this referring to our neighbors as a “vagrancy problem” is sinful in a couple ways. First, there’s no humanity in it. People should not be referred to as a problem. Full stop. Second, the problem here is not our neighbors. The problem is that we live in a world where some have so much and others have so little. The problem is that low-wage jobs don’t cover the high cost of housing in our community. The problem is that people born into poverty typically do not have adequate means to access education and training to get out of poverty. The problem is that safety nets for those experiencing mental health and addiction issues are worn so thin, they’re barely hanging together.
We talked about what we can do as faith leaders to help change attitudes about our neighbors. And I said, “You know, we have so many stories in our faith traditions about hospitality and about caring for those on the margins. Those stories are incredibly powerful. But fewer and fewer people participate regularly in a community of faith. I hope that the people in our congregation know those stories and take them to heart. I hope they would feel them bubbling up inside if they ever heard someone refer to our neighbors as a ‘vagrancy problem.’ I hope they would speak up and gently correct the person - maybe even by telling a Biblical story.”
Our stories are powerful. And our stories are currently very much at odds with some of the other stories we’re hearing out there in our country.
Speaking of sin, earlier this week I found myself exploring the ICE website. I know, I know. I sacrificed my algorithm so you don’t have to. I found myself there because I saw a social media post from the Department of Homeland Security and it was so shockingly atrocious that I had to verify it was real.
It said: “Serve your country! Defend your culture! No undergraduate degree required! Join dot ice dot gov”
I’m sorry to say, it was real. I’m also sorry to say that if you click through to the ICE website you get an image of Uncle Sam pointing his finger at you, saying “America Needs You! America has been invaded by criminals and predators. We need YOU to get them out.” And then it advertises a signing bonus of up to $50,000 and student loan repayment of up to $60,000.
And if you click through ad actually look at the jobs available, hoo boy, many of them have a starting pay of $90- $110- $120,000 a year. $100k a year to commit atrocities, but we can’t find money for……take your choice - fill in the blank.
These other stories are also powerful. Stories of xenophobia and fear of outsiders are currently running rampant. Stories that attempt to justify the dehumanization of our neighbors. Stories that pit us against them. Stories that try to conflate “serving your country” with locking people up in cages. And “defending your culture” with kidnapping children and disappearing beloved parents, aunties, and grandfathers.
A culture that glorifies white supremacy and Christian nationlism? This is not the culture Christ-followers have been taught to defend.
Instead, our stories - the ones Jesus taught - point to a different way. A way rooted in kindness, compassion, and care. A way that reminds us to love every single other. A way that compels us to shout on behalf of those who have been silenced. A way that insists there is enough and spare - for everyone. A way that insists we keep hope alive even when we are in the depths of despair. A way that reminds us, as Rabbi Dr. Joachim Prinz said, “Neighbor is not a geographic term. It is a moral concept.” [1]
What did Jesus say was the most important thing? “Love God. And love your neighbor as yourself.” And who are our neighbors according to Jesus? Well, there’s a whole story about that and you can find it in Luke 10, but we’ve got to get keep keepin on here or we’ll never get to the sin of Soddom.
Now, I know what you’ve been taught about Sodom. If there’s one thing anyone knows about this story it’s that it’s about the sin of homosexuality, right?
Wrong.
That’s not the issue here.
What IS the issue is that when strangers show up at the gate, enter the city for the night, and seek shelter, the citizens of Sodom react as though they are under direct attack.
“Sodom Needs You! Sodom has been invaded by criminals and predators. We need YOU to get them out!”
While Lot has welcomed the strangers (who are angels, we’re told) warmly, the men of Sodom want nothing to do with them. Lot welcomes them at the gate, insists they stay in his home rather than on the streets, feeds them dinner, and comes to their defense when danger comes knocking at the door.
The men of Sodom angrily yell at Lot: “Where are the men who came to you tonight? Bring them out to us, so that we may know them.” Or some translations say, “so we can have sex with them.” The Message says, “so we can have our sport with them.” But let’s be more accurate: they were threatening to rape them. And, as we know, rape isn’t really about sex, it’s about power and control. And in this instance, it’s about an attempt to exert power over vulnerable guests. It’s about fear of the other that leads to violence. It’s about “defending our culture” from outsiders.
Incidentally, I don’t want to gloss over Lot’s horrific behavior in the 19th chapter of Genesis. I’m still salty that he’s never called out for his sin (see what I did there?). When the mob arrives at his doorstep, asking him to sacrifice the guests to the rapacious crowd, Lot attempts to protect them by offering up his daughters instead. I know. It’s awful. There’s nothing I can say to redeem his actions here.
The men of Sodom are angry at Lot for another reason, though. They say, “Who does this immigrant think he is, judging us? Do what we say or we’re gonna hurt you worse than we planned on hurting them.” In other words, “Don’t forget, Lot. You’re an outsider, too. And we don’t like outsiders around here. Go back where you came from.”
There is a broad consensus among biblical scholars that the sins of Sodom were inhospitality and arrogance. These men thought they were better than everyone else around them, especially foreigners. And rather than welcoming the strangers in their midst, rather than seeing travelers as neighbors imbued with the image of God, they saw them as threats. They labeled them “problem” and dehumanized them. In their fear and loathing, they lashed out in a show of dominance and with threats of violence.
There’s nothing uplifting about the story of Sodom and Gomorrah. It’s a sad, scary story. Lot begged God to save the city, if he could only find 10 decent people there.
In the end, he couldn’t save them. They were too far gone.
It’s not an uplifting story. It’s a cautionary tale. A tale about what can happen when a group of people listen to the wrong stories for too long. A reminder that our sacred stories compel us to live lives rooted in hospitality, bravery, compassion, and respect for all our neighbors.
It’s up to us to stand up for kindness and decency. It’s up to us to look around and see who is being left out or is at risk, and make sure they’re taken care of. And let’s promise to do it in a less problematic way than Lot did, okay?
We have our sacred stories of neighboring to light the way and give us strength.
When the voices of fear and hate are loud, we give thanks for our alternative narratives of love and care. May we never stop telling the stories. And may we never stop listening with open hearts.
NOTES:
[1] https://www.joachimprinz.com/civilrights.htm